"Whenever the people are well-informed, they can be trusted with their own government." Thomas Jefferson

The Pope and Bernie Sanders: Misguided Economic Missionaries

Melanie Sturm | @ThinkAgainUSA Read Comments - 17
Publish Date: 
Thu, 10/08/2015


If only Pope Francis were in my Buenos Aires taxi last Christmas.


I could have used his moral authority (and Argentine-accented Spanish) in negotiating with a driver who’d forgotten the “Golden Rule.” And in witnessing my struggle, the self-described “very allergic to economics” pontiff might have gleaned a moral lesson, helping him Think Again about the free enterprise system he’s criticized.


Perhaps he’d grasp why the life-enhancing innovations that America continuously exports – cars, vaccinations, refrigerators, iPhones, 3-D printers, and the cheap and reliable taxi-alternative Uber, for which I longed – don’t happen in Argentina. 


Nor do they spring from other Latin American countries, like Venezuela where a protest sign encapsulated people’s contempt for the social-justice espousing frauds who run many Latin nations:  “These Castro-Chavistas speak like Marx, govern like Stalin, and live like Rockefeller, while the people suffer.”


Would His Holiness recognize how Argentina’s corporatism – the unholy alliance between government and conglomerates – corrodes social trust, rendering his countrymen voiceless and crucifying their wellbeing and dignity?


After successive governments eroded the rule of law, property rights, and sound money, replacing free enterprise with central planning and a debt-financed welfare state, Argentina slid toward the bottom of the Fraser Institute’s Economic Freedom of the World Index.


Once the world’s breadbasket and fourth-richest nation per-capita – hence the saying “rich as an Argentine” – the Pope’s native land is now a basket case with economic wellbeing (GDP per-capita) only one-third America’s.


If the Holy Father had heard our cabdriver despair over widespread deprivation, corruption and distrust of everyone except the pontiff, might he agree with fellow rock-star Bono about how to lift up the masses? “In dealing with poverty,” Bono stresses, “welfare and foreign aid are a Band-Aid. Free enterprise is a cure.”


The patient is mending, the World Bank reported: For the first time in history, extreme poverty afflicts less than 10 percent of world population. Meanwhile, people in economically freer countries enjoy higher living standards, cleaner environments, longer lives, and better-protected civil rights. They also have less corruption, child labor and unemployment.


In his new book, “The Conservative Heart,” American Enterprise Institute President Arthur Brooks calls the free enterprise system “America’s gift to the world,” enabling more people to pursue their happiness through earned success derived from work.


“It was the free enterprise system that not only attracted millions of the world’s poor to our shores and gave them lives of dignity, but also empowered billions more worldwide to pull themselves out of poverty,” Brooks asserts.


At home, however, America’s asymmetric recovery “has cleaved the country into winners and losers like never before,” he writes.  Consequently, Americans fear our free society’s trademarks – opportunity and social mobility – are disappearing, imperiling our children’s security and prosperity. 


We may be better off than Argentines, but with median income down 6.5 percent since 2007, record numbers out of the workforce, poverty and government dependency rates at all-time highs, and deaths of small businesses (job creation’s primary engine) exceeding starts for the first time on record, it feels like we’re slouching toward Argentina.


While Wall Street and Silicon Valley have boomed, the richest and most generous nation on earth contains pockets of destitution and immiseration – like Baltimore – where millions are deprived of the dignity and fulfillment of work.


Brooks’ snapshot of the last seven years is “deja-vu all over again,” Argentine-style: “People see corporate cronies getting rich because of their cozy relationship with the government. They see bailouts for huge banks but small businesses going bust. They see government loan guarantees for big companies with friends in high places, but hear ‘No loans for you’ from their local bank.”


Ranked among the world’s most economically free nations for decades, America has fallen to 16 in Fraser’s Index, due to these unfair government policies. Consequently, US annual growth is projected to be half its 3 percent historic average.


That His Holiness is unaware of the relationship between economic freedom and human flourishing is a sin, though not original. After all, presidential candidate Bernie Sanders sins similarly, arguing for greater government control of our lives, even at the expense of economic growth.


“You don’t necessarily need a choice of 23 underarm spray deodorants,” Sanders declared, “when children are hungry in this country” – as if narrowing deodorant choice could decrease hunger.


The truth is, poverty is humanity’s natural state, and free enterprise is the most merciful economic system yet designed for moving people toward productive and dignified lives. No central planner exists who’s capable of improving on the endless autonomous decisions made efficiently, creatively and cooperatively in the free market, as if divinely guided.


Think Again – as long as we enjoy the blessings of economic freedom, we have the choice not to attend the Pope Francis & Bernie Sanders School of Economics where the tuition is free, but extraordinarily costly, as my Argentine cabbie would confirm.


Share this

With all due respect, ceding

With all due respect, ceding the leader of 1.3 billion Catholics to the Left like this article does is not a way to persuade people about socialism. It risks doing quite the opposite.

Don't stick Sanders and Francis in the same boat. They just don't belong there.

Your article was very

Your article was very thoughtful and respectful.

My father's family used to live there and we still have friends in Argentina. I'll never forget how friends had to build their new home around the existing house. Because interest rates are so high, loans are prohibitive. It was a years long process. I am Catholic, but I really wish the Pope would stick to church doctrine.

Loved your two recent columns

Loved your two recent columns on the Pope and the climate "groupthinkers" Global warming is the premiere cottage industry and the man-made mantra is a gigantic fraud, regardless of how many of the perpetrators actually believe it. Two long-time friends of mine have been battling this issue at www.CFACT.org.

As for the Pope (not the "Holy Father," a title which is unbiblical), his ignorance and foolishness on economics and climate are disturbing, as is his cowardliness on speaking out on the growing and pervasive moral failings in America and worldwide, in sharp contrast to his immediate predecessors. I've long since departed from the Catholic Church, but it's amazing to observe the dubious direction its headed with this man at the helm.

Best wishes, and please keep up the great work!

If the Pope is concerned

If the Pope is concerned about global warming (this might sound harsh from a Catholic) perhaps the church needs to discover ‘birth control’ since the bottom billion account for 25% of the air pollution by burning wood to cook food (or maybe he can suggest that they eat cold cuts).

His stance on capitalism is hypocritical when in the same breath he wants the people from South America to have free access to the ‘north’. So, he disrespects what capitalism has done to save the world but wants us to take care of people from the failed socialist states down south.

It’s just crazy.

I agree with you 100%,

I agree with you 100%, however I was disappointed with your political correctness in referring to the Pope as Holy Father and His Holiness.

In my humble opinion, he is a sinner just like the rest of us, and therefore equal to us, and also Jesus taught us to not call anyone on earth our "Father". I do not know your beliefs, but that is what I gather from God's Holy word.

Once again an awesome column.

Once again an awesome column. My only comment, and I rarely offer them, is that the Pope, starting as a lowly priest, spoke out many, many times against Argentina's systems including corrupt alliances and lack of economic freedoms. I'm not Catholic by the way.

You hit it out of the park

You hit it out of the park again! History will show that the Obama administration was yet another failure in its attempt to bring Socialism to America. I believe common sense will prevail.

Such great feedback as I

Such great feedback as I struggled about whether to tell more of the taxi driver story, deciding instead to use my words to quote Arthur Brooks later in the column.

I'd hoped to encapsulate the frustrating story merely by saying that the driver had forgotten the Golden Rule so readers would make the connection between the corroded civil society he represents and the unfair government policies that incentivize people to be less virtuous.

The Sanders quote -- which captures the absurdity of socialism -- was helpful in discrediting a politician who's drawing extraordinary crowds, given his ideas. People are enamored of his authenticity, but do they realize how damaging his economic philosophy is? Hopefully by suggesting that we are slouching toward Argentina, people will think again about his devastating economic philosophy.

Thank you all for this fantastic dialogue!

Oh, and by the way.....My story had a satisfying ending not shared in the column. After getting fleeced by a cabdriver who trusted no one except the Pope, I starred him down before exiting the cab and said, “Feliz Navidad!” The irony was palpable, and my message was caught.

Do unto others as you would

Do unto others as you would have done unto you is not being followed by those in control in socialist governments.

So what's the link to the

So what's the link to the Golden Rule?

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • No HTML tags allowed
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Article List

Thu, 09/10/2015

Thu, 09/12/2013

Thu, 06/06/2013

Tue, 01/15/2013

Thu, 05/24/2012

Thu, 03/15/2012

Thu, 07/07/2011

Thu, 03/31/2011