"Whenever the people are well-informed, they can be trusted with their own government." Thomas Jefferson

The Unbearable Lightness of Being Indebted

Melanie Sturm | @ThinkAgainUSA Read Comments - 10
Publish Date: 
Thu, 05/23/2013

“Fat, drunk, and stupid is no way to go through life,” counseled Faber College’s Dean Wormer in “Animal House.” For the collegiate class of 2013 -- until next year the most indebted ever – add “in hock” to that immortal list. 

Compared to their parents, current graduates are paying four times more in inflation-adjusted terms for their diplomas while suffering substantially inferior job and income prospects. Like Animal House’s witless frat-brothers, those who believe college is a “last hurrah” before plunging into adult reality must Think Again.

For generations, Americans practiced what Benjamin Franklin preached – “an investment in knowledge pays the best interest” – believing a college degree was an affordable yet golden ticket to independence, a satisfying career, financial security and an “open sesame” to American society. Even students without credit histories or clear plans for the future could borrow the necessary sums to pursue impractical majors like ethnic studies, take six years to graduate, and still land jobs with incomes sufficient to pay down debt.

Today however, a college degree is substantially riskier due to mushrooming global supplies, ever-inflating U.S. diploma prices, and a more selective, chaotic and stressful market for college graduates. Though a B.A. carries a certification premium with employers, it conveys little about actual qualifications, especially considering recent studies of higher education outcomes (surveyed in the 2011 book “Academically Adrift”) which show how little knowledge, critical thinking and skills acquisition occur between an undergraduate’s freshman and senior years.

Because its risk/reward ratio is out-of-whack, it’s no longer a truism that you’ll get out of college what you put into it. Among those under 25-years-old, 53 percent are either unemployed or in jobs that don’t require a bachelor’s degree, a high for this demographic since record keeping began in 1948.

As in the housing bubble, easy credit and expectations of ever-increasing returns on education investments buoyed demand for college diplomas. To capture federal money, academic institutions hiked tuition causing students to incur more debt, diminishing the degree’s reward. Since 1978, tuition has grown 7.5 percent annually, far outpacing inflation and family incomes, which increased 3.8 percent and 5.0 percent respectively.

Because many colleges operate like mortgage brokers, even encouraging students who are academic risks to take on debt, two-thirds of freshmen borrow while one-third of those with loans leave degreeless. Consequently, the portfolio of federally guaranteed student loans has grown to $1 trillion -- up 70 percent since 2008, exceeding total credit card debt. Considering government loans aren’t dischargeable, even in bankruptcy, many are sacrificing their dreams including further education, marriage, kids and homeownership.

The biggest victims are those the system was designed to bolster – marginal students. Just as federal lending policies helped inflate the housing bubble undermining the ability of low-income home buyers to ascend into the middle class, federal student loan policies have backfired, consigning indebted and degreeless Americans to the low end of the labor market without incomes sufficient to pay off debts.

Given these sad realities, former Education Secretary Bill Bennett poses a frequently asked question in his book “Is College Worth It?” Students whose lifetime earnings potential comfortably exceeds their debt -- achievable with sought-after degrees like petroleum engineering or prestigious credentials like a Stanford diploma – should go. However, “two-thirds of people who go to four-year colleges right out of high school should do something else,” especially considering Bureau of Labor Statistics predictions that 7 of the top 10 fastest-growing jobs require on-the-job training, not higher education.

At the heart of America’s education crisis is the implicit goal to leave no child behind without a college degree, as if the college campus were the optimal garden for all children to flourish.  Parents and teachers appreciate how distinctive and diversely talented kids are. Yet our K-12 “one-size-fits-all” system emphasizes and tracks academic abilities -- often at the exclusion of non-academic aptitudes – and without great success considering reading and math scores are no higher for 17-year-olds than they were in 1970, despite an inflation-adjusted tripling of K-12 education spending.

The consequence of our misplaced focus on college is that many brilliantly talented and creative people believe they’re not because their unique abilities were devalued at school. Wouldn’t our kids be better served if educational success meant enabling students to reach adulthood aware of their native abilities and passions and inspired to realize their full potential? Wouldn’t society be enhanced by a richer conception of human capacity that appreciates diverse talents and rewards what one knows and can do, not one’s salary?

New education start-ups that use online technologies – like the recently announced MIT/Harvard joint venture -- have the potential to revolutionize education, offering students affordable courses to “do what you can, with what you have, where you are,” as Theodore Roosevelt urged. 

Think Again – isn’t lifting kids from where they are to a better place in life the point of education?

Share this

Thanks Melanie, this thinking

Thanks Melanie, this thinking needs to be shouted from the roof top of every high school in our nation.

My company is actively involved with local and distant high schools wood shop, engineering and business classes in an effort to "grow" our own employees. But the Educational Industrial Complex fights us at every turn. High schools are little more than the university systems minor leagues, always preaching that EVERYONE MUST GO TO COLLEGE!

So sad to see how talented and skilled young people get sucked into the higher education system by the lure of "scholarships" that only cover a portion of the costs with loans that can never be repaid making up the difference.

This may be shocking, but

This may be shocking, but college isn't for everybody! The value of your college education depends greatly on your chosen major. If you want your college debt incurred to be worthwhile, then you should choose something that will be valuable to society and thus prospective employers. This isn't hard, people! If you're going to school for some "underwater basket weaving" kind of degree, you're probably going to have a hard time paying back your loan.

I read an article a while

I read an article a while back about poor college graduates who couldn't find jobs. The article explained that the students didn't understand the debt burden until 2 years into their degree, and that while someone could try to explain it to high schoolers, 17-year-olds just can't understand. My question is, if they can't understand it in high school how are they smart enough to be being accepted to college?

Nice article. I'm not sure I

Nice article. I'm not sure I agree with the second half of this sentence though, "Because its risk-reward ratio is out of whack, it’s no longer a truism that you’ll get out of college what you put into it."

I think you do get out what you put in, but sadly way too many people think showing up (maybe), getting drunk 5 nights a week and coasting through is going to prepare them for a job when they graduate. I think the cost is outrageous these days, and most private schools are nowhere close to a good investment, but I still think students who really commit themselves and recognize the opportunity they have to learn over those 4 years, prepare themselves to do very well in society.

The real problem is the cost of not being that prepared student is immensely higher today than it has ever been.

Good stuff. What a racket the

Good stuff. What a racket the whole college complex has become.

Having had one of my kids in college each of the last ten years I have to tell you that even the in-state costs have gone through the roof. Thankfully, the youngest will graduate next year.

Start saving!

Cloward-Piven will happen

Cloward-Piven will happen when huge numbers of people begin voting themselves loan forgiveness. The candidate could be Hitler 2.0 and it won’t matter.

Its hard to add to such an

Its hard to add to such an intuitive and informative opinion. I will be passing this on to my large network of contacts starting with Facebook. Melanie, keep on rockin baby, this battle message must be proclaimed. Wrote this on the Times website. Mayor Moore

Back in my day, any

Back in my day, any government college loan went straight to the school, not to the student. When was this changed so the "student" could get their hands directly on the cash? Maybe I should go back to school. I could always use some extra money!

The Denver Post had

The Denver Post had interviews with the "Occupy Denver" radicals, and most of them (in their late 20s or early 30s) claimed to be "students." Not hard guessing how they were supporting themselves.

It was right after 0bama was

It was right after 0bama was elected that he put the government in charge of student loans. Since then I have watched my friends´ children clamor for this easy money; some just drop out after getting the money and they use the money for travel. Another son and his wife subsidize their expense living habits by each getting these easy loans, and they take one course on-line, and they spend the rest on clothes and cars. The college loan business that 0bama set up is a scam and now well over a Trillion Dollars that will come down crashing on our heads any day.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • No HTML tags allowed
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Article List

Thu, 09/10/2015

Thu, 09/12/2013

Thu, 06/06/2013

Tue, 01/15/2013

Thu, 05/24/2012

Thu, 03/15/2012

Thu, 07/07/2011

Thu, 03/31/2011